General interest mega-boards and forum sustainability
-
I think it's a good idea.
The magic of forums is here to stay, and it will only get stronger with time and new features.
-
@julian That would be really a great addition.
-
I think this is a great idea! Our users already enjoy being able to form their own groups, and would likely be interested in creating categories to go with them as well.
-
This is an excellent idea, as demonstrated by the fact that many self-created communities (≈categories) on Lemmy have achieved significant global success. However, Lemmy's implementation is unsatisfactory and needs to be adjusted. I am the administrator of a Lemmy instance as well as a NodeBB instance, and I must admit that at the height of Lemmy's development, we never allowed autonomous community creation. This was due to some issues that arose with mastodon when homonymous communities and users existed. It was also because it was impossible to implement an approval process or ensure that the quality of the communities met the instance's standards. For this reason, the process for creating communities by users consisted of a request from the registered user and a creation reserved for administrators.
What I would like to see in NodeBB is the ability to create communities, but keep them in a sort of "limbo," a "section" where new communities remain until they reach acceptable quality levels for the instance's standards.
This is in addition to the entire user credit system, which I imagine could also be set up to achieve a suitable score for building a community.
Perhaps I'm asking too much, but NodeBB's development has been so impressive so far that I wouldn't be surprised if you could implement a feature like this.
-
@julian Still interested in this feature. Was the idea dropped?
-
@bh4-tech no, not at all. It's actually going to be our next focus of work for NodeBB, with funding from NLNet

-
Not sure my opinion counts as it's been almost 2 years since I seriously looked into forum admin, and I just peek in here from time to time because I like the cozier feel of old-school forums compared to modern social media.
Anyway, I don't see the harm in allowing users to create their own communities assuming the feature is off by default. My only issue, and I'm not sure it's even an issue, is that this, along with NodeBB's use of ActivityPub, pushes NodeBB into the niche of other Threadiverse platforms like Lemmy and Piefed. The only difference is the terms used and default presentation. Don't get me wrong the defaults have a HUGE impact on community culture. As I've pointed out elsewhere something as simple as the default sorting order of posts effects how people browse, post, and organize the content they present. Lemmy is, by default, a stream of new content, whereas forums are, by default, a place for long-lasting discussions.
Allowing user-created subforums would, I suspect, have a similarly huge effect on how NodeBB communities are run by mods and admins and how they feel to users.
-
@anchorite The net effect would be zero if it was a bundled as a feature of the NodeBB platform, Admin enabled/disabled, and not an out of the box default.
-
@omega @anchorite questions here at the high level would involve whether we do this as a plugin or in core directly.
I agree that we'd want to keep this off by default (or perhaps have a welcome configurator to handle things like AP or user created categories)
I imagine moderation would be handled by the community creators directly... With admins having a light touch.